Britten: War Requiem; Sinfonia da Requiem; Ballad of Heroes

Editorial Reviews
Amazon.com
While not quite the equal of Britten's own performance, Richard Hickox's version is so good that it's pointless to quibble about this or that detail. It also has two big advantages over the composer's own recording: stunning digital sound and two spectacularly performed couplings that are related in subject and mood to the main work. In fact, if you have room for only one Britten disc in you collection, this should be it. You get a comprehensive overview of the issues that concerned this most compassionate of composers: the horror of war, the corruption of innocence, and the firm belief in the power of hope. --David Hurwitz

Britten: War Requiem; Sinfonia da Requiem; Ballad of Heroes, Music, Adrianne Hill, Benjamin Britten, Richard Hickox, London Symphony Chamber Orchestra, London Symphony Chorus, London Symphony Orchestra, London Symphony Orchestra and Chamber Orchestra, Roderick Elms, Heather Harper, Martyn Hill, Philip Langridge, John Shirley-Quirk, 20th/21st Century Symphony, Choral, Classical, Classical Composers, Classical Music, Orchestral & Symphonic, Requiem/Requiem Section, Secular Music for Soloists, Chorus and Instruments, Symphonic

Britten: War Requiem; Sinfonia da Requiem; Ballad of Heroes
Average customer rating:

Comparing Hickox to other War Requiems

The Most Consistent Recording

Too late, alas, too late

The War Requiem that tops even Britten's own recording

An essential recording

Britten: War Requiem; Sinfonia da Requiem; Ballad of Heroes

Manufacturer: Chandos
ProductGroup: Music
Binding: Audio CD

All Works by Britten | Britten, Sir Benjamin | ( B ) | Featured Composers, A-Z | Classical | Styles | Music
Requiems | Forms & Genres | Early Music | Historical Periods | Classical | Styles | Music
Symphonies | Forms & Genres | Modern, 20th, & 21st Century | Historical Periods | Classical | Styles | Music
General | Symphonies | Classical | Styles | Music
Modern & 20th Century | Symphonies | Classical | Styles | Music
General | Classical | Styles | Music
General | Opera & Vocal | Styles | Music
Requiems | Vocal Non-Opera | Opera & Vocal | Styles | Music
Similar Items:

Britten - Peter Grimes / Pears · C. Watson · Pease · Brannigan · J. Watson · Elms · Studholme · Kells · R. Nilsson · Lanigan · G. Evans · D. Kelly · ROH Covent Garden · Britten

Bruckner: Die 3 Messen/Masses Nos. 1-3/Les Messes

Bartók: Violin Sonatas

Britten: Piano Concerto / Violin Concerto

Josquin: L'homme armé Masses

ASIN: B000000ANS
Release Date: 1992-09-30

Tracks:

War Requiem Op.66: I. Requiem Aeternam
War Requiem Op.66: II. Dies Irae
War Requiem Op.66: III. Offertorium
War Requiem Op.66: IV. Santctus
War Requiem Op.66: V. Agnus Dei

Tracks:

War Requiem Op.66: VI. Libera Me
Sinf Da Requiem Op.20: I. Lacrymosa: Andante Ben Misurato - LSO & CO/Richard Hickox
Sinf Da Requiem Op.20: II. Dies Irae: Allegro Con Fuoco-Alla Marcia-Avanti! - LSO & CO/Richard Hickox
Sinf Da Requiem Op.20: III. Requiem Aeternam: Andante Molto Tranquillo - LSO & CO/Richard Hickox
Ballad Of Heroes Op.14: I. Funeral March: Allegro Moderato-Lento Alla Marcia - Martyn Hill/London Sym Chor/Richard Hickox
Ballad Of Heroes Op.14: II. Scherzo (Dance Of Death): Allegro Con Fuoco-Molto Pesante... - Martyn Hill/London Sym Chor/Richard Hickox
Ballad Of Heroes Op.14: III. Recitative And Choral: Lento Quasi Recitativo-Lento E Tranquillo... - Martyn Hill/London Sym Chor/Richard Hickox

Amazon.com

While not quite the equal of Britten's own performance, Richard Hickox's version is so good that it's pointless to quibble about this or that detail. It also has two big advantages over the composer's own recording: stunning digital sound and two spectacularly performed couplings that are related in subject and mood to the main work. In fact, if you have room for only one Britten disc in you collection, this should be it. You get a comprehensive overview of the issues that concerned this most compassionate of composers: the horror of war, the corruption of innocence, and the firm belief in the power of hope. --David Hurwitz

Customer Reviews:

Comparing Hickox to other War Requiems.......2006-09-20

I wholeheartedly agree with the reviewers below who are so enthusiastic about Hickox's 1991 War Requiem, the best in the thirty years after the premiere recording. I've heard various other sets, which struck me as follows: John Eliot Gardiner's on DG, recorded with a German orchestra and his own Monteverdi Choir, has unlistenable, shrill sonics and soloists not well attuned to Owen's poetry. Rattle is much better (EMI) but feels a little underplayed to me, despite excellent forces all around. Masur with the NY Phil. (Teldec) is much too cautious, despite the excellent duo of Thomas Hampson and Jerry Hadley in the male solo parts. A budget issue from Naxos recorded at a summer festival in Scotland, directed by Martyn Brabbins, is quite powerful and direct, with particularly excellent choral work but too-literal soloists.

Which narrows the choice down to Britten's Decca recording and this one, both with the London Sym. Both also have excellent sonics, though Chandos's digital engineering is more close-up and impactful. This adds to the passionate drama of Hickox's interpretation, contrasted to the more elegaic, mournful tone of Britten's. If you want maximum excitement, this is the recording to get. In the solo parts, I recognize the unique position Peter Pears occupied in Britten's music, but for beauty of voice, he's excelled by Langridge for Hickox, who's nearly as sensitive and poetic.

Between the two baritones, I have no hesitation preferring Shirley-Quirk over Fischer-Dieskau. Britten was making a pacifist point by picking a singer from Germany in the post-Nazi era, but F-D's command of English can't compare to Shirley-Quirk, who also blessedly lacks F-D's bark and bluster. Neither soprano is ideal, Vishnevskaya being too piercing (as Slavic sopranos tend to be) and Heather Harper, though graceful and sincere, past her prime.

On both sets the LSO plays magnificently and the various choirs, adult and children's, are exemplary--though again, Hickox's dramatic thrust and the closer miking from Chandos give more visceral impact to the choruses in his recording. I've tried to impartially summarize each version, and overall I am glad to own both. If you wanted only one? My choice would be the Hickox, for the reasons already stated.

The Most Consistent Recording.......2006-07-16

Having listened to most of the other interpretations of Britten's War Requiem, I found this version to have the best overall quality, especially Heather Harper managing to avoid the shrill, piercing sounds other sopranos have made in the same part.

As a bonus, you also get the instrumental Sinfonia da Requiem, an piece written for the 2000th anniversary of Japan's emperor's dynasty (it was rejected), and Ballad of Heroes, a sort of miniature but no less effective piece in the mold of War Requiem.

An essential buy for War Requiem/Britten fans.

Too late, alas, too late.......2005-08-16

When Vishnevaskaya was denied permission to leave the USSR, it was Heather Harper who stepped in at just 10 days notice to learn the part and sing at the premiere of War Requiem (like Messiah, it has no definite article) in Coventry Cathedral. That was the best part of 30 years before this recording was made. And therein lies the tragedy. No-one who heard that premiere or many of the early subsequent performances in which she sang could every forget the glory of her Rex Tremendae or the heartbreak of the Lacrymosa or indeed any of her part then. Sadly, by the time of this recording, the voice was no longer what it was - some of the brilliance at the top had gone, some of the richness and warmth in its middle-register, too. So this performance is a wonderful reminder of those glory days and is certainly invested with all the depth and understanding of her experience of the piece - but what a shame she wasn't recorded years before.

Some of the same could be said of John Shirley-Quirk in the baritone part. In the days of those early performances it was usually Tom Hemsley (a sadly underrepresented singer on disc) who took the role. Nevertheless, Shirley-Quirk, too, must be said to be a little past his prime by the time of this Hickox recording. The voice, which never had quite the edge Hemsley brought to his singing of the more bitterly ironic Owen poems, was when in its prime more than a match for Fischer-Dieskau (who sang at the premiere and on the Britten recording) in smoothness and warmth. No question but that some of that had gone by the time of this performance. But there is much to admire in Shirley-Quirk's singing here, especially in his familiar sensitivity and responsiveness to the text. Again...if only it had been a few years earlier in his career.

Langridge, as always, presents a very real alternative to the Peter Pears point of view in Britten. This is a voice still very much in its prime and a very different voice to Pears, for whom the part was written. No, he can't quite match the original tenor's ineffably and uniquely smooth way of singing through 'the break' in passages such as the Dona nobis pacem at the end of the Agnus Dei. But the irony of a piece like 'Out There' or the bitter heartbreak of 'Move Him into the Sun' are both absolutely masterful in Langridge's performance. And the final pages as the two dead enemies sing each other to sleep are as moving as ever.

Hickox conducts a fine performance - he knows his Britten well and all his experience as a chorus master is put to outstanding effect in the singing of the London Symphony Chorus. Inevitably, there are not quite the insights given us by the composer himself in his still unequalled first recording, but this is still a substantial performance - if tinged with sadness that Harper and Shirley-Quirk weren't caught in their prime.

The War Requiem that tops even Britten's own recording.......2002-03-27

I own three different recordings of Britten's War Requiem (his own recording on Decca; the EMI recording with Simon Rattle conducting, which is a close second in my view; and this Richard Hickox recording, which I purchased as soon as it was released several years ago).

This one is still the tops in overall sound quality, interpretation and sheer power. If anyone has ever hesitated in trying to get to know this work, or is new to classical music and exploring, or loves Britten's War Requiem and wants the best recording available, this one is it, hands down. I have never heard a performance of the "Sanctus" with as much depth and luminosity as this one.

By the way, many other Richard Hickox recordings on the Chandos label are worth exploring, but for the sake of brevity, I will not list them here.

An essential recording.......2002-02-24

I doubt that we will ever have a recording of the War Requiem that will top this one overall. The soloists, chorus, orchestra and musical interpretation are all first rate. The audio engineering has created an extremely open sound with perfect balance between the chorus and the soloists. The result of all this technical and artistic brilliance is a profoundly moving experience for the listener, who is left with feelings of awe and angst, which is almost certainly what Britten wanted. Given the present mood of the world, the anti-war sentiments contained in this Requiem may not sit well with some, but they are valid and true, nonetheless. This is Britten's masterpiece and is certainly one of the greatest musical compositions of the twentieth century. Someday, its greatness will be widely recognized.

Tracks:

I. Requiem Aeternam - John Shirley-Quirk
II. Dies Irae - John Shirley-Quirk
III. Offertorium - John Shirley-Quirk
IV. Sanctus - John Shirley-Quirk
V. Agnus Dei - John Shirley-Quirk

Tracks:

VI. Libera Me - John Shirley-Quirk
I. Lacrymosa. Andante Ben Misurato - Martyn Hill
II. Dies Irae. Allegro Con Fuoco - Alla Marcia - Avanti! - Martyn Hill
III. Requiem Aeternam. Andante Molto Tranquillo - Martyn Hill
I. Funeral March. Allegro Moderato - Lento All Marcia - Martyn Hill
II. Scherzo: Dance Of Death: Allegro Con Fuoco - Molto Pesante - Allegro Con Fuoco - Martyn Hill
III. Recitative And Choral. Lento Quasi Recitativo - Lento E Tranquillo - Epilogue. Tempo 1 (Funeral March) - Martyn Hill

Music Review:

Music Review

music review

Music Review

Eradicate the Doubt [Import]

Liebe, Schnaps, Tod: Hannes Wader singt Bellman

Heifetz Collection, Vol. 35

Buena Suerte Senorita

Music Review: 4 the Love of the Game

Live at Manchester University [Live] [Import]

Focus on: Brazilian Pop [Import]

Greatest [Limited Edition] [Import]

Hammond vs Drums

James Galway & The Chieftains in Ireland

Fellow Needs a Girl [Import] [Original recording remastered]

El Desquite

En Vivo Gira 2005 [Live]

The AIDS Quilt Songbook

Live in San Francisco at Stern Grove