Bartok: 6 String Quartets [Import]

Editorial Reviews
Album Details
This is One of Those Performances Though Great You'd Never Expect to Come Out on CD (And in the States Didn't Since Dg Didn't Want Another Version to Compete with the Other One Already on their Label by the Emerson Quartet- who Incidentally Are Dull as Dish Water Compared to These Guys). From the Opening Measure of the First Quartet One Becomes Immediately Aware that this Group Literally and Figuratively Has this Music in their Blood. Those who Love These Works Or Bartok in General Are Strongly Encouraged to Consider this Idiomatically Incomparable, Stylish, and Truly Important Set.

Bartok: 6 String Quartets, Music, Hungarian String Quartet, Bela Bartok, Classical

Bela Bartok: The 6 String Quartets - Emerson String Quartet
Average customer rating:

Compositions: Outstanding! Performance: Mixed.

Great technique but little soul

Brilliant playing, but lacking color and flavor

The Bartok Cycle at its Best

As usual, the Emerson's just don't get it

Bela Bartok: The 6 String Quartets - Emerson String Quartet
Eugene Drucker , Lawrence Dutton , David Finckel , Philip Setzer , and Emerson String Quartet
Manufacturer: Deutsche Grammophon
ProductGroup: Music
Binding: Audio CD

Quartets | Chamber Music | Classical | Styles | Music
General | Chamber Music | Classical | Styles | Music
General | Bartók, Béla | ( B ) | Featured Composers, A-Z | Classical | Styles | Music
Emerson String Quartet | ( E ) | Featured Performers, A-Z | Classical | Styles | Music
General | Classical | Styles | Music
Deutsche Grammophon: Music | Specialty Stores | Music
Similar Items:

Debussy, Ravel: Streichquartette

Shostakovich: The String Quartets

Beethoven: The String Quartets

Dvorák, Tchaikovsky, Borodin: Quartets

Shostakovich: The String Quartets

ASIN: B000001G9O
Release Date: 1990-10-25

Tracks:

String Quartet No. 1, Op. 7: 1. Lento - attacca
String Quartet No. 1, Op. 7: 2. Poco e poco accelerande all' Allegretto - Introduzione. Allegro 0 attacca
String Quartet No. 1, Op. 7: 3. Allegro vivace
String Quartet No. 3: 1. Prima Parte: Moderato - attacca
String Quartet No. 3: 2. Seconda parte: Allegro - attacca: Ricapitulazione della prima parte; Moderato
String Quartet No. 3: 3. Coda: Allegro molto
String Quartet No. 5: 1. Alllegro
String Quartet No. 5: 2. Adagio molto
String Quartet No. 5: 3. Scherzo: Alla bulgarese
String Quartet No. 5: 4. Andante
String Quartet No. 5: 5. Finale: Allegro vivace

Tracks:

String Quartet No. 2, Op. 17: 1. Moderato
String Quartet No. 2, Op. 17: 2. Allegro molto capriccioso
String Quartet No. 2, Op. 17: 3. Lento
String Quartet No. 4: 1. Allegro
String Quartet, No. 4: 2. Prestissimo, con sordino
String Quartet, No. 4: 3. Non troppo lento
String Quartet, No. 4: 4. Allegretto pizzicato
String Quartet, No. 4: 5. Allegro molto
STRING QUARTET NO. 6: 1. Mesto-piu mosso, pensante - Vivace
STRING QUARTET NO. 6: 2. Mesto - Marcia
STRING QUARTET NO. 6: 3. Mesto - Burletta
STRING QUARTET NO. 6: 4. Mesto

Amazon.com

The six quartets of Bartók have been well represented on record, far better than the six of Schoenberg or the fifteen of Shostakovich. The choice on Compact Disc, however, is an easy one, for the Emerson Quartet not only plays the music better than any other ensemble, but gets all six essays onto two discs. Making roses out of what must seem more like a collection of thistles to most others who attempt to play the set, the Emerson players show the kind of ensemble polish that caused one European critic to complain, "too smooth.... I like my Bartók rougher." But awkwardness and rhythmic uncertainty, which have made many a lesser group sound rough in this music, should not be confused with expressive edge, which the Emersons bring to the music in full measure. Their readings are extraordinarily revealing, high-intensity, not at all for the faint of heart. With the odd-numbered quartets on one disc and the even on the other, each CD is a "microcosmos" of the whole set. The sound quality is excellent throughout. --Ted Libbey

Customer Reviews:

Compositions: Outstanding! Performance: Mixed........2007-06-05

One reviewer said that Emerson wasn't rough enough. When this was released, I believe it was the roughest interpretation I had ever heard! Over-all, these are very good performances (and 100% accurate). The weakness of these performances is the gentler sections which, though technically perfect, lack feeling and conviction. Béla Bartók: The Six String Quartets - Juilliard String Quartet does a very good job of the quiet sections, but lacks power on the aggressive parts.

My favorite recording of these pieces is Bartók: 6 String Quartets by the Hungarian String Quartet. Since I bought that I haven't listened to other recordings of this piece.

Great technique but little soul.......2007-05-12

The Emersons blow through Bartok's most difficult passages with masterly aplomb; their virtuosity is never in question, and if you were not already familiar with these works you might think these performances were definitive. Bartok, however had a mysterious and lyrical side to him, and the Emersons don't illuminate those remarkable moments in these performances. I constantly get the impression that the Emersons are determined not to let Bartok push them around. They manhandle him masterfully, throwing him to the ground and leaving him in the gutter. Bartok deserves more sympathy than that. With the Emersons it is the bravura playing that will give you goose bumps, not Bartok's dark visions.

Brilliant playing, but lacking color and flavor.......2007-01-03

I've had this album for several years and have played it often, but I have come to be less than satisfied because of the lack of tone color in these performances. Bartok was, among other things, a Hungarian nationalist composer and a colorist. For me, these performances do not reflect the full color and nationalistic flavor that other performances have shown.

The Bartok Cycle at its Best.......2006-08-17

This cycle won 2 Grammophone Awardsin 1989 for Record of the Year and Best Chamber Music Performance, and 2 Grammys in 1990 for Best Classical Recording and Best Chamber Music Performance. After listening to them it is easy to see why. Bartok's string quartets have never sounded better. The closest rivals for my ears is the Takacs performances which I also own and love.

Enough has been written regarding their technical skills. In these, as in many other of their albums, they also provide us with an insightful interpretation.

Highly recommended.

As usual, the Emerson's just don't get it.......2006-02-09

Yes, they play very well, they are always in tune, and they can play as fast as they choose - but they don't understand the music. If you want a great version of these works, take a listen to the Hungarian Quartet on DG, or the Tokyo Quartet on RCA.

Béla Bartók: The 6 String Quartets - Takács Quartet

Average customer rating:

go for Tokyo
Spectacular
Lacklustre insight ... airbrushed production.
The third way.
Finally, they get it

Béla Bartók: The 6 String Quartets - Takács Quartet
Edward Dusinberre , Andras Fejer , Karoly Schranz , Roger Tapping , and Takács Quartet
Manufacturer: Decca
ProductGroup: Music
Binding: Audio CD

Quartets | Chamber Music | Classical | Styles | Music

General | Chamber Music | Classical | Styles | Music

General | Classical | Styles | Music

The Decca Records Store | Specialty Stores | Music
Similar Items:

Beethoven: String Quartets
Beethoven: The Late String Quartets
Beethoven: String Quartets Op. 18
Bartok: Complete Solo Piano Music
Shostakovich: The String Quartets

ASIN: B0000042GU
Release Date: 1998-01-13

Tracks:

String Quartet No. 1, op. 7 (Sz 40): I. Lento
String Quartet No. 1, op. 7 (Sz 40): II. Poco a poco accelerando all'allegretto
String Quartet No. 1, op. 7 (Sz 40): III. Introduzione Allegro - Allegro vivace
String Quartet No. 3(Sz 85): I. Prima parte: Moderato
String Quartet No. 3(Sz 85): II. Seconda Parte: Allegro
String Quartet No. 3(Sz 85): III. Ricapitulazione della prima parte: Moderato - Coda: Allegro molto
String Quartet No. 5 (Sz 85): I. Allegro
String Quartet No. 5 (Sz 85): II. Adagio molto
String Quartet No. 5 (Sz 85): III. Scherzo. Alla bulgarese -- Trio
String Quartet No. 5 (Sz 85): IV. Andante
String Quartet No. 5 (Sz 85): V. Finale: Allegro vivace -- Presto

Tracks:

String Quartet No. 2, op. 17 (Sz 67): I. Moderato
String Quartet No. 2, op. 17 (Sz 67): II. Allegro molto capriccioso
String Quartet No. 2, op. 17 (Sz 67): III. Lento
String Quartet No. 4, (Sz 91): I. Allegro
String Quartet No. 4, (Sz 91): II. Prestissimo, con sordino
String Quartet No. 4, (Sz 91): III. Non troppo lento
String Quartet No. 4, (Sz 91): IV. Allegretto pizzicato
String Quartet No. 4, (Sz 91): V. Allegro molto
String Quartet No. 6 (Sz 114): I. Mesto - Piso, pesante - Vivace
String Quartet No. 6 (Sz 114): II. Mesto - Marcia
String Quartet No. 6 (Sz 114): III. Mesto - Burletta: Moderato
IV. Mesto

Amazon.com's Best of 1998

If chamber music suggests merely sedate and timid pleasures, let the Takács Quartet guide you through the profound experience that this medium can convey--above all in the hands of a composer as rich in imagination and innovative in temperament as Béla Bartók. In some ways his cycle of string quartets traces not only his personal creative evolution but the deeply tragic zeitgeist of half a century as well. The Takács Quartet plays with an unfaltering sense for the lifeblood of this music in performances that are both gutsy and ethereal. --Thomas May

Amazon.com essential recording

Béla Bartók has emerged as one of the few modern masters who continue to be regularly performed and recorded. The six string quartets that span his career from 1908 to 1939 are generally regarded as this century's unsurpassed addition to the medium, and they provide an intimate entrée into the world of their withdrawn and enigmatic composer. With this cycle, the Takács Quartet confirms its reputation, against some very fierce competition, as possibly the most cogent, exciting exponent of this music today. They achieve an unusually successful synthesis of the quartets' polarizing components: lyrically haunting "night music," passages of grotesquely ironic humor, and, in the Sixth Quartet, an unrelentingly pervasive sense of desolation and farewell. In the process, the Takács players give visceral life to the extremities of technique Bartók's scores demand. These range from exaggerated glissandi to pizzicati made to snap violently against the fingerboard, at times producing a sound more akin to a percussion battery than a string quartet. The ensemble convincingly traverses Bartók's creative evolution, from the hothouse romanticism of the First Quartet to the Third's densely packed modernist fury and the palindrome structures of the Fourth and Fifth Quartets. Richly nuanced with local color, these accounts are among the best available on disc and will likely become standard-setters. --Thomas May

Customer Reviews:

go for Tokyo.......2006-08-28

Bartok is not a likely candidate for frequent recordings in the 21st century. Before it is too late you should acquire the Tokyo version on RCA (including the Janacek quartets). Besides being a bargain (2 composers for the price of 1), you get passionate playing and sound that is excellent. Do not be swayed by anyone who says Decca (inventor of the "tree" after all) knows how to record anything. It does depend on your speakers (headphones). I have owned systems on which the Tokyo String Quartet did not sound good. Well, this is about the Takacs. They are relatively bloodless (do any of you really hear passion in this recording?). There are many who would say that that's the way Bartok should sound. But the Tokyo is like Heffler and Mikrokosmos--he sounds much better than Ranki whether or not he's authentic.

Spectacular.......2006-01-31

I bought this CD in preparation for the Takacs Quartet's performance of the Bartok cycle in January of 2005. This recording is absolutely amazing, and it brings out the liveliness and the joy that the members of the Quartet take in playing this piece. Now, make sure you get the chance to see this group live; you will be amazed and astounded by their cohesiveness and energy.

Lacklustre insight ... airbrushed production. .......2005-11-01

A medium to large hall ambience smooths & smudges it all. An inappropriate production decision for these quartets.
The playing lacks the emotional concentration & forensic insight needed - they have their moments but overall it just doesn't involve you like it should. The overall effect is of an airbrushed quality - the result is lacklustre.
I grew up on the landmark 1960's Juilliard readings, so you may know where I'm coming from, and what I expect to hear. It so happens that is what works best for this music, which is why those are legendary performance recordings.
After that these fall very far short. As Sony are still not re-releasing those classics, buy the Emerson Qt. recordings instead - they are of a similar quality to - and in the spirit of - the Juilliard's reading.

The third way........2005-10-04

I've recently bought this cycle, after having or listening those by Tokyo String Quartet (DG & RCA), Hagen Quartett (DG), Alban Berg Quartett (EMI), Vegh Qt (Auvidis) and some other versions played by outstanding quartets, like the glorius Arditti Quartet's recording of the Fourth Quartet in Grammavision label.

If I'm thinking about a third way is because Takács shows a middle interpretation between the very hungarian performings of the Vegh Qt and the very "international" or "western" playing of the Tokyo Qt, ABQ or Hagen Qt versions. The Takács Quartet that play in this CD box is formed by musicians from the western tradition and hungarian born players, 50%; something you can feel in their interpretation, which is a bit more objective than Takács' first recording released by Hungaroton, with more hungarian players in the quartet, but still with the taste of the hungarian Bartók tradition, much more close to the popular and folk reminiscences of his music.

I don't hear in this performings the amazing precision of the Tokyo String Quartet in every pizzicatti, glissandi, or technical resource of the works; but, on the other hand, I can say that the musicality and folk sense of some parts it's better done in this Decca recording, which looks much more to the origin of some chords in the folk hungarian music which Bartók so deep has studied. Takács (Decca) bring a more aggressive version, something that makes very complex to have the precision of the more refine and "distant" Tokyo performings. Anyway, technically it's marvellous too, and that's the reason why I give them 4 stars... 5 stars only in heaven...

The conclusion is we are listening a very good performances of the cycle, in style and technique, one of the key works in this genre along the XXth Century; probably between the better.

Finally, they get it.......2005-08-31

Bartok has been called many things, but one thing I wish he would be called more often is a mystic of music. In my over-educated opinion, that is what he was, and that dominated him as a composer, a pianist, an ethnomusicologist and a pedagogue. The problem is that many performers come to this music very naive or, worse, dismissive of this quality of Bartok's genius, and focus too heavily on technical apsects. The result is obvious: a failure to give a proper and authentic voice to the music.

I am sympathetic to the dilemma of any performer tackling these quartets - these are very demanding on a technical level alone. But this does not mean their beauty resides purely in that facet, nor does it excuse any performer for rendering these as a technical or academic exercise. Suffice to say, some performers just don't "get it," and thus ought not attempt these works, if they are not able to met the technical challenge they present and then transcend it in spirit to articulate their fuller beauty.

As a musician who's studied Bartok academically, I am very aware on an intellectual level of how these works relate to Bartok's studies in folk music, and I can easily pick out and analyze his inversions and sequences of folk motifs that populate these works. However, all too often this is something not easily *heard* by the average listener - a tragic irony, seeing much of Bartok's work is so rooted in folk music, which is possibly the most accessible of music idioms. Sadly, this is a mystic's lot: they experience something that is univerally accessible, yet in the process of articulating that experience, those first recieving the message miss the point, get destracted by superficial details, and obscure the beauty and truth of the mystic's message for everyone else. Luckily, music can speak for itself - if the performer doesn't get in the way. So if the performer understands, either consciously or intuitively, that there is a *heart* to these works beyond what he sees written so precisely and techinically on the page (i.e. "gets it"), and strives to articulate this, then that engimatic mysicism of Bartok is unlocked and becomes readily accessible to anyone willing to peer into it.

Fortunately and thankfully, the Takacs Quartet "get it." This is very likely the finest performance of these quartets ever recorded. Without repeating too much of what other reviewers have already said, there is a very genuine spirit and superior command to the Takacs Quartet's performance that makes the very challenging and highly technical quality of these quartets transparent so to reveal, rather than obscure, Bartok's vision. They open up Bartok's quartets in a rare way that allow the listener to "live" inside them, and glaze readily upon their beauty, possibly very closely to how Bartok originally envisioned it. I listened to this recording immediately after listening the 1960's recording by the Novak Quartet, and the difference was astounding. It only vindicated my long standing opinion that Bartok was indeed a mystic of music, and that his unique and very challenging compositions offer much, much more (and for a wider audience) than one might assume from a less inspired performance.

Absolutey, unequivocally recommended.

Average customer rating:

Bartók: 6 String Quartets

Manufacturer: Deutsche Grammophon
ProductGroup: Music
Binding: Audio CD

Quartets | Chamber Music | Classical | Styles | Music

General | Chamber Music | Classical | Styles | Music

General | Classical | Styles | Music

Deutsche Grammophon: Music | Specialty Stores | Music

More Titles at Least 20% Off | Classical Music Blowout | Stores | Music

All Classical Music Blowout | Classical Music Blowout | Stores | Music

Instrumental | Classical Music Blowout | Stores | Music
Similar Items:

Beethoven - The Complete String Quartets / Alban Berg Quartet
Tchaikovsky, Sibelius: Violin Concertos
Arnold Schoenberg: Serenade/Five Pieces For Orchestra
Bach: Concertos
György Ligeti Edition 1: String Quartets and Duets - Arditti String Quartet

ASIN: B000LC4B34
Release Date: 2007-02-13

Tracks:

1. Lento-Attacca
2. Poco A Poco Accelerando All'Allegretto-Introduzione. Allegro-Attacca
3. Allegro Vivace
1. Prima Parte. Moderato-Attacca
2. Seconda Parte. Allegro-Attacca: Ricapitualazione Della Prima Parte. Moderato
3. Coda. Allegro Molto
1. Allegro
2. Adagio Molto
3. Scherzo. Alla Bulgarese
4. Andante
5. Finale. Allegro Vivace

Tracks:

1. Moderato
2. Allegro Molto Capriccioso
3. Lento
1. Allegro
2. Prestissimo, Con Sordino
3. Non Troppo Lento
4. Allegretto Pizzicato
5. Allegro Molto
1. Mesto-Piu Mosso, Pesante-Vivace
2. Mesto-Marcia
3. Mesto-Burletta
4. Mesto

Béla Bartók: The Six String Quartets - Juilliard String Quartet

Average customer rating:

Compositions: Outstanding! Performance: Mixed.
Doesn't compare to the 1963 Juilliard version
Beautiful music, poor rendition
Julliard interprets Bartok's works excellently
a neoclassical reading at a bargain price

Béla Bartók: The Six String Quartets - Juilliard String Quartet
Robert Mann , Earl Carlyss , Joel Krosnick , Samuel [viola] Rhodes , and Juilliard String Quartet
Manufacturer: Sony
ProductGroup: Music
Binding: Audio CD

Quartets | Chamber Music | Classical | Styles | Music

General | Chamber Music | Classical | Styles | Music

General | Classical | Styles | Music

Classical Music | The Sony BMG Masterworks Store | Amazon.com Label Stores | Stores | Music
ASIN: B0000029YN
Release Date: 1997-11-18

Tracks:

The Six String Quartets: String Quartet No.1, Op.7 - Lento - Bartok
The Six String Quartets: Allegretto - Bartok
The Six String Quartets: Allegro Vivace - Bartok
The Six String Quartets: String Quartet No.2, Op.17 - Moderato - Bartok
The Six String Quartets: Allegro Molto Capriccioso - Bartok
The Six String Quartets: Lento - Bartok
The Six String Quartets: String Quartett No.3 - Prima Parte: Moderato - Bartok
The Six String Quartets: Seconda Parte: Allegro - Bartok
The Six String Quartets: Ricapitulazione Della Prima Parte: Moderato - Bartok
The Six String Quartets: Coda: Allegro Molto - Bartok
The Six String Quartets: String Quartet No.4 - Allegro - Bartok

Tracks:

The Six String Quartets: String Quartet No. 4 - Prestissimo, Con Sordino - Bela Bartok
The Six String Quartets: Non Troppo Lento - Bela Bartok
The Six String Quartets: Allegretto Pizzicato - Bela Bartok
The Six String Quartets: Allegro Molto - Bela Bartok
The Six String Quartets: String Quartet No. 5 - Allegro - Bela Bartok
The Six String Quartets: Adagio Molto - Bela Bartok
The Six String Quartets: Scherzo - Alla Bulgarese - Bela Bartok
The Six String Quartets: Andante - Bela Bartok
The Six String Quartets: Finale - Allegro Vivace - Bela Bartok
The Six String Quartets: String Quartet No. 6 - Mesto- Vivace - Bela Bartok
The Six String Quartets: Mesto - Marcia - Bela Bartok
The Six String Quartets: Mesto - Burletta - Moderato - Bela Bartok
The Six String Quartets: Mesto - Bela Bartok

Amazon.com essential recording

The Juilliard Quartet burst upon the international musical scene in the 1950s with a series of acclaimed performances of the six Bartók string quartets. Five decades later they are still renowned for their performances of this music, and no one interested in this superb group can afford to pass up this set, digitally recorded in 1981 and now available at budget price. These quartets have been very frequently recorded over the years, but few more recent versions match the Juilliard in terms of both interpretive and technical excellence. --David Hurwitz

Customer Reviews:

Compositions: Outstanding! Performance: Mixed........2007-06-04

These are great pieces of music and the Juilliard Quartet performs the slow movements beautifully. The fast movements are accurate, but lacking impact. The recording quality is fairly good. Bela Bartok: The 6 String Quartets - Emerson String Quartet does a better job of the fast movements, but not as well on the slow movements. I would recommend the Hungarian String Quartet Bartók: 6 String Quartets recording instead.

P.S. I saw the Juilliard String Quartet perform Bartok's 5th string quartet in 2005 and it was phenomenal. I'm just reviewing the recording here, not today's quartet!

Doesn't compare to the 1963 Juilliard version.......2003-11-11

It is a shame that the 1981 Juilliard cycle has been the only available Juilliard cycle for some time, because it is by far the weakest of the three. Sure, it is a relatively cheap CD set, but I don't really feel it is worth the money. The playing, compared to the Juilliard's incomparable 1963 recording, is positively anemic. The sound quality also leaves a lot to be desired. Overall, this is an unsatisfying listening experience.

If you want the 1963 Juilliard version, good luck. It is available only as an import, and is generally a challenge to acquire. The same can be said of the Alban Berg Quartett cycle. Probably the best domestically available version would be the Emerson Quartet's cycle.

Some people may be thinking that they are getting the 1963 version with this CD set. Don't be fooled --- this version is significantly inferior and should definitely not be your first choice.

Beautiful music, poor rendition.......2003-08-06

It has been said that Bartok's string quartets together are the best thing to happen to classical music since Beethoven's string quartets. There are many wonderful quartets out there performing these quartets, but this recording by the Juilliard Quartet just doesn't rank up there. I swear by the Emerson Quartet's rendition on Deutsche Grammophon which has wonderful recording quality and an amazing performance. I've heard the Takacs Quartet live and they indeed have their own wonderful way of interpreting the music that's different from the Emerson Quartet. I'd recommend either quartet's work heartily over the Juilliard's version, which is thin, lifeless, and simply unsatisfying. Don't think you're saving money -- you'll just end up buying one of the better versions anyway!

Julliard interprets Bartok's works excellently.......2002-12-10

There are better interpretations of these seminal works available -- Takacs Quartet and Emerson Quartet do excellent versions, I'm told -- but for someone on a budget who would love to hear six great, innovative string quartets, you can't beat this disc.

A two-disc set recorded in 1981 by the famed Julliard String Quartet, this collection takes what are considered by many to be the finest string quartets ever written and gives them a clear, beautiful interpretation. While the first two (and last) quartets are quiet and contemplative, things get really exciting in the middle portion, with 3, 4 and 5 bristling with energy and tension. This is "modern" classical at its finest.

Julliard shows why Bartok was such a revered composer. If you want to go all out and get the aforementioned Takacs or Emerson versions, I'm sure you'll be sonically rewarded. But two excellent discs for under $15 is a great deal.

a neoclassical reading at a bargain price.......2001-08-16

Bartok composed the great string quartet cycle of the early 20th century. Of the various available recordings, this Juilliard from 1981 has one obvious advantage -- it's cheaper. By all means, listen, it's a fine version, but you'll never know what you're missing if you don't hear the Takacs Quartet's "gypsy" version!

The 3rd, 4th, and 5th quartets are sheer modernist genius. The 1st and 2nd are less innovative -- the 1st is in the romantic tradition. The 6th is calm and tragic, written as Bartok prepared to leave Hungary for the USA.

Here are some comparisons between the Juilliard and Takacs recordings -- an advantage of the Juilliard is that the quartets are in order, while the Takacs changes the order. The resulting disadvantage of the Juilliard is that #4 is split. The Juilliard has perfunctory liner notes, while the Takacs has superb, extensive liner notes describing each piece and how it was written. As for the music, these are very different interpretations. The Juilliard Quartet sounds quite neoclassical -- light, even thin, restrained, and emphasizing the ensemble more than individual lines. In dramatic contrast, the Takacs Quartet sounds rougher, earthier, "gypsy" -- they are heavier, thicker, more passionate, and sound more like four individuals playing together than a unified ensemble. So far, a matter of interpretation. Both are valid, and the differences highlight the rich potential of the scores. BUT, there is a serious problem with the Juilliard, and that is why I give it only 4 stars -- the recording seems to slight the bass end, with a faint cello. The Juilliard recording of Carter's quartets doesn't suffer from this problem, and so I have to conclude that the problem is in the recording, not the playing. The recording of the Takacs disc is superb and balanced, and is probably partly responsible for the sound of four distinct lines.

Tracks:

I. Allegro
II. Adagio
III. Scherzo
IV. Andante
V. Allegro Vivace
I. Mesto - Piu Mosso, Pesante - Vivace
II. Mesto - Marcia
III. Mesto - Burletta: Moderato
IV. Mesto

Amazon.com

The Arcanto Quartet is an extraordinary group. Unlike most quartets, it was formed not by young, still developing musicians, but by four mature artists, well-known as soloists, ensemble players, and conservatory professors who, after trying one another out in different combinations, decided to form a string quartet. Founded in 2002, it first appeared in Stuttgart two years later, and since then has performed widely in Germany and Japan. This is its debut recording, and it is terrific. The players are all superb; the two violinists are completely equal. In only a few years, these four musicians have found a single style for their separate personalities. Their tone blends homogeneously, yet remains individually distinct. They can alternate between taking the lead and receding into the background seamlessly and unnoticeably. Their intonation is impeccable, their articulation unanimous; they weave a clear contrapuntal texture from multi-colored strands and build climaxes upon each others' phrases within a huge dynamic range. They make Bartók's constantly changing rhythms and idiomatic syncopations rock-steady but not stiff and fit meticulously observed details into a cohesive whole. They express the sometimes wildly contrasting moods and feelings of the music with all the power of personal identification and achieve an enormous emotional impact. --Edith Eisler

Average customer rating:

Adequate but not stirring
Very consistent, from start to finish over 2 CD's
Great music, OK performance

Bartók: Six String Quartets

Manufacturer: Philips
ProductGroup: Music
Binding: Audio CD

Quartets | Chamber Music | Classical | Styles | Music

General | Chamber Music | Classical | Styles | Music

General | Classical | Styles | Music
Similar Items:

Schoenberg: The String Quartets

ASIN: B000004199
Release Date: 1994-08-16

Tracks:

String Quartet No. 1 In A Minor, Op. 7: 1. Lento
String Quartet No. 1 In A Minor, Op. 7: 2. Allegretto
String Quartet No. 1 In A Minor, Op. 7: 3. Introduzione. Allegro - Allegro vivace
String Quartet No. 3: Prima parte. Moderato
String Quartet No. 3: Seconda parte. Allegro
String Quartet No. 3: Ricapitolazione della prima parte. Moderato
String Quartet No. 3: Coda. Allegro molto
String Quartet No. 5: 1. Allegro
String Quartet No. 5: 2. Adagio molto
String Quartet No. 5: 3. Scherzo
String Quartet No. 5: 4. Andante
String Quartet No. 5: 5. Finale

Tracks:

String Quartet No. 2 In A Minor, Op. 17: Moderato
String Quartet No. 2 In A Minor, Op. 17: Allegro molto capriccioso
String Quartet No. 2 In A Minor, Op. 17: Lento
String Quartet No. 4: 1. Allegro
String Quartet No. 4: 2. Prestissimo, con sordino
String Quartet No. 4: 3. Non troppo lento
String Quartet No. 4: 4. Allegretto pizzicato
String Quartet No. 4: 5. Allegro molto
STRING QUARTET NO. 6: 1. Mesto -Vivace
STRING QUARTET NO. 6: 2. Mesto - Marcia
STRING QUARTET NO. 6: 3. Mesto - Burletta. Moderato
STRING QUARTET NO. 6: 4. Mesto

Customer Reviews:

Adequate but not stirring.......2006-10-09

One has to respect any quartet that can deliver decent performances of these difficult works, but I can't say that this performance rises above merely adequate. The recording is lacking in clarity, but the real problem is the performance. Rhythmically hazy, texturally obscure and with only mediocre ensemble, my search for a good version of these quartets continues.

Very consistent, from start to finish over 2 CD's.......2006-04-17

The strength of this 2 CD release, is the CONSISTENT
style, audio quality, mood from start to finish.

There are 6 compositions on this release, lasting
well almost 2 hours.

This release definitively shows the composer's
ability to exude the moody and dark emotions that
humans can go through, at times. And to be exposed
to such an audio experience for well over an hour,
at very high audio quality, with the full "aching"
of the wood instruments to reflect on one's emotions
is exceptional and unique.

I feel these compositions are unique, in that sense...
they take the listener to a mental and emotional landscape
where the listener is very much alive, yet very much
aware of the sad emotions that are shown, which is
totally different to other music, that often is nihilist,
negative, self-destructive which is totally unrelated to
this work.

As such, much like a physical wound is medically damaged
and on the mend, these 2 CD's offer a musical experience
that is rich in sound and vitality, yet painful to listen
in its beauty.

Great music, OK performance.......2000-11-22

There is no question, at least in my mind, that the 20th century master of the string quartet was Bela Bartok. The remarkable thing to note is that Bartok did not even play strings! He was a virtuosic pianist. So how does someone who doesn't even play strings end up with a technique named after him (The Bartok Pizzicato)? The man was a genius, that's all I can say.

These quartets should appeal to a broad base of listeners, especially today. I think that more teens would be into "classical music" if they were introduced to these quartets (especially those into "heavy metal") and realized the potential of the medium. Our ears are much less sensitive to dissonance than they were when these debuted, so most people should be fairly comfortable with the material. Perhaps not on the first listen, but after a little exposure.

This particular performance, however, I have found rather lacking. It just doesn't grab me. It seems to be a rather cold interpretation that lacks any spirit (in material where it abounds!). I don't like the sonic quality of the recording either -- it sounds very flat and one-dimensional.

Customer Reviews:

Milestone recordings!.......2006-12-27

The music of Bartok (1881-1945) is original, exciting, mysterious. Around his music nothing is superfluous, incidental, emotional; everything is sturdy, supported by a forceful energy. The process of link of each phrase or section seems to be product of an organic approach.

For many listeners Bartok `s String Quartets is an enormous wasteland. Like Shstakovich, Bartok opens his soul in this genre because there is major creative liberty and universes to explore.

This 1954cycle was released on commercially under Angel label in the U.S. and the French Columbia on three LPs But thanks to Music& Arts efforts the rescue of this important historical document has been possible.

It is always worthy to remark the presence of the exhaustive energy of Sandor Vegh, an exceptional music who surmounted the conventional barriers of the musical interpretation to get into in the great luminaries and established several landmark recordings as member of the Hungarian, Vegh quartet and finally as conductor of the Salzburg Mozarteum's Camerata Academica (from 1978 to 1997).

To classify the artistic quality and the performance level of these recordings would be simply unsurpassable, not only by the performances by themselves but the idiomatic expression, the ethos and gestalt which were played.

Since I got this double album, it's my favorite choice at the moment to enjoy and travel by this universe.

Average customer rating:

Total Bartok

Bartok: Complete String Quartets

Manufacturer: Naive
ProductGroup: Music
Binding: Audio CD

Quartets | Chamber Music | Classical | Styles | Music

General | Chamber Music | Classical | Styles | Music

General | Classical | Styles | Music

Classical | Imports | Stores | Music
ASIN: B000059OBK
Release Date: 2001-08-14

Customer Reviews:

Total Bartok.......2003-02-21

I don't know what else to say. I have never felt so completely involved in this music (the Takacs recording comes very close, with state of the art sound -- I'm glad to have both sets). Listening to these quartets in sequence -- the 3 disks permit a chronological progression -- is a revelation, as one moves from the romantacism of the First Quartet to the final, elegaic Sixth. The 2nd disk contains the thorniest works: quartets 3 and 4. Listening to them together, as played by the Vegh Quartet, I sensed the distillation of all that can be expressed in music within these highly concentrated forms. Yet these are earthy, swaggering performances at the same time -- physically and intellectually stimulating.

"Now, even potted palms might rejoice
to hear this counterpoint, these lambent chords.
The infinitely baffled speakers voice
a heart-to-heart that leaves me wanting words."

Tracks:

String Quartet No. 1 Op.7
Sting Quartet No.3
String Quartet No. 5
String Quartet No. 2
String Quartet No. 4
String Quartet No. 6

Album Details

This is One of Those Performances Though Great You'd Never Expect to Come Out on CD (And in the States Didn't Since Dg Didn't Want Another Version to Compete with the Other One Already on their Label by the Emerson Quartet- who Incidentally Are Dull as Dish Water Compared to These Guys). From the Opening Measure of the First Quartet One Becomes Immediately Aware that this Group Literally and Figuratively Has this Music in their Blood. Those who Love These Works Or Bartok in General Are Strongly Encouraged to Consider this Idiomatically Incomparable, Stylish, and Truly Important Set.

Customer Reviews:

Inspired! My favorite recording of Bartok's Quartets.......2007-06-04

The Hungarian quartet plays each note as though they are improvising. This recording is crystal clear and the performance is positively inspiring. They do take some very minor liberties, occasionally substituting pizz for arco or vice-versa. This in no way diminishes the strength of these recordings, but it is interesting to note.

I own the Emerson Quartet's recording and the 1950's Juilliard Recording, and have heard the Juilliard perform the 5th quartet live in 2005. The Emerson is ferocious in the fast sections, but seems somewhat lifeless in the slow movements. The Juilliard plays the slow sections beautifully, but the faster sections sound mechanical. Both recordings are 100% accurate to the score. But every time I want to hear these pieces, I play the Hungarian version, whether following the score or not.

Other versions of note:

- I once heard some of the fabled 1960's Juilliard String Quartet recording (not available on CD). It was wonderful, but that was too long ago for me to be able to compare it to this recording.

- I have it from a very reliable source that the Vegh Quartet version Bartok: Complete String Quartets is excellent, but I've never heard it.

The great Bartok.......2006-08-05

Bartok's quartets are among the greatest of the last century, they are difficult to appreciate but the Hungarian quartet make the job easier, their playing is superb and they handle these works with power, vigor and depth. If you are a fan of Bartok don't miss this record, it is one of the best!!!

First class all the way!.......2006-03-23

Excellent recording and performance; having heard a live performance many years ago in two nights of performance when no-one was performing Bartok in the U.S, it brought back wonderful memories. Absolutely superb!

Beautiful recording!.......2006-03-08

This rendition of Bartok is a wonderful performance and I would add that the recording quality is superlative. One of the reasons I enjoy strings is their tonal quality or timbre, and this recording excels in that regard; really gorgeous sounding instruments, great recording technique, and a soulful display of fine musicianship. Stylistically, it's a slower interpretation than I had expected, having become acquainted with the Emerson version before this one. I find myself in awe of the beauty of the tone and sonorities and the genuine emotion conveyed in this work. ;-)

Don't Neglect this performance.......2005-10-05

For years I had the Novak recording of this set of quartets and found the quartets sort of lifeless and rarely listened to them. I set out to find a recording that would bring these quartets to life.
I listened to the Emerson Quartet performance. Techniquely it is outstanding but it really sounds rushed and is almost too classical -- lacking some of the folk "sound" that Bartok likes to put into his music -- which can be found in these quartets.
This Hugarian String Quartet recording has the balance between technical accuracy and Hugarian folksong understanding. It is thrilling and will make your heart beat fast. The sound is great and the tempi are just right -- never pushed, but never lacking energy. This is not at all a boring performance. This performance will open your eyes as to why these quartets are so spectacular.
While this is a performance in the early 60's, the sound is rich and at least as good as the more recent performances.
I read the Penquin review of the quartets. They question why this set is considered a Legendary Recording by DGG. I am not sure what the motivations were for discounting this recording, and I cannot agree with the Penguin review on this disc.
I think that this Original Legendary Recording should not be neglected. It is a powerful and moving listening experience. I am actually surprised that it is not an Amazon Essential Recording.
Go for it.