Grechaninov: Symphony 5/Missa oecumenica

Editorial Reviews
From International Record Review - subscribe now
When does a Mass not sound like a Mass? Well, quite often actually, but it is true that few even of those that do not really sound like Masses sound quite like Grechaninov's Missa oecumenica. One is initially nonplussed to hear the Latin words set to such fervently Russian music – there are even fragments of symphonic Tchaikovsky peeping through in several of the movements. It really ought to be in Slavonic, be more like Janácek's Glagolitic Mass, but then that was not the point: according to the critic Joseph Yasser (quoted in Eric Roseberry's notes), ‘Grechaninov has always fought against isolationism of spiritual faith, and has refused to follow the narrow traditionalism of sacred music. Indeed, he loves Western and Russian church music equally well.' If many Orthodox believers would say that this is simply abandoning sacred tradition (and such could be said in the case of the instrumentally accompanied Orthodox Liturgia Domestica as well), it must not be forgotten that what most think of as Russian sacred music today is deeply influenced by the West. In this context, one could view this Mass – not the only one the composer wrote, of course – as a ‘Russian revenge', and it certainly betrays its composer's Orthodox roots far more than, say, Pärt's Berliner Messe, another contribution to the liturgy of the West by an Orthodox composer. It possesses, from a strictly musical point of view, much beautiful writing. The interesting mixture of pseudo-organum and Russian passion in the Sanctus and the lyrical Agnus Dei are particularly memorable, though in the final analysis the work is rather too diffuse to make a lasting impression.

The Fifth Symphony, written in the same year, is inevitably a more wide-ranging work, with, in spite of its rather Borodin-like roots, an obvious personality of its own and a luminous optimism all the more notable for having been written under the shadow of war. The second movement, a fine Andante, and the finale, with what Roseberry justly calls its ‘unstoppable momentum towards a life-affirming conclusion', are extremely impressive; the work certainly deserves to be much better known than it is. Polyansky elicits splendid and utterly idiomatic performances of both works from the Russian State Symphony Orchestra and Symphonic Cappella.

Ivan Moody

Grechaninov: Symphony 5/Missa oecumenica, Music, Alexander Tikhonovich Grechaninov, Valery Polyansky, Ludmila Kuznetsova, Tatiana Sharova, Oleg Dolgov, 20th/21st Century Symphony, Choral, Choral Music, Classical, Classical Composers, Classical Music, Orchestral & Symphonic, Symphonic
Grechaninov: Symphony 5/Missa oecumenica
Average customer rating: Not rated
    		Grechaninov: Symphony 5/Missa oecumenica

    Manufacturer: Chandos
    ProductGroup: Music
    Binding: Audio CD

    SymphoniesSymphonies | Forms & Genres | Modern, 20th, & 21st Century | Historical Periods | Classical | Styles | Music
    GeneralGeneral | Symphonies | Classical | Styles | Music
    Modern & 20th CenturyModern & 20th Century | Symphonies | Classical | Styles | Music
    GeneralGeneral | Classical | Styles | Music
    GeneralGeneral | Opera & Vocal | Styles | Music
    Similar Items:
    1. Grechaninov: Symphony No.4/Cello Concerto/Missa Festiva
    2. Grechaninov: Symphony No. 3; Cantata 'Praise the Lord'
    3. Grechaninov: Mass 'Et in terra pax'; Symphony No. 2
    4. Grechaninov: Symphony No. 1; Snowflakes; Missa Sancti Spiritus

    ASIN: B00004YU71
    Release Date: 2000-11-28

    Tracks:

    1. Missa Oecumenica, Op.142: I. Kyrie - Tatiana Sharova/Ludmila Kuznetsova/Oleg Dolgov/Dmitry Fadeyev/Margarita Koroleva...
    2. Missa Oecumenica, Op.142: II. Gloria - Tatiana Sharova/Ludmila Kuznetsova/Oleg Dolgov/Dmitry Fadeyev/Margarita Koroleva...
    3. Missa Oecumenica, Op.142: III. Credo - Tatiana Sharova/Ludmila Kuznetsova/Oleg Dolgov/Dmitry Fadeyev/Margarita Koroleva...
    4. Missa Oecumenica, Op.142: IV. Sanctus - Tatiana Sharova/Ludmila Kuznetsova/Oleg Dolgov/Dmitry Fadeyev/Margarita Koroleva...
    5. Missa Oecumenica, Op.142: V. Benedictus - Tatiana Sharova/Ludmila Kuznetsova/Oleg Dolgov/Dmitry Fadeyev/Margarita Koroleva...
    6. Missa Oecumenica, Op.142: VI. Agnus Dei - Tatiana Sharova/Ludmila Kuznetsova/Oleg Dolgov/Dmitry Fadeyev/Margarita Koroleva...
    7. Sym No.5 in g, Op.153: I. Maestoso - - Russian State Symphonic Orch/Valeri Polyansky
    8. Sym No.5 in g, Op.153: II. Andante - - Russian State Symphonic Orch/Valeri Polyansky
    9. Sym No.5 in g, Op.153: III. Scherzo: Allegro - - Russian State Symphonic Orch/Valeri Polyansky
    10. Sym No.5 in g, Op.153: IV: Finale: Allegro Moderato - Russian State Symphonic Orch/Valeri Polyansky

    Music Review:

    1. GRIEG: Peer Gynt / Radio Orchestra Cologne / Froschauer 2CD
    2. Hatikvah!: Richard Tucker Sings Great Jewish Favorites
    3. Home Grown
    4. In The Shadow Of World War II: Cello Sonatas Composed In The Aftermath Of WWII
    5. Irish Girl
    6. Kancheli: Trauerfarbenes Land, ...a la Duduki / Davies, Vienna Radio Symphony Orch
    7. Klassizische Moderne, Vol. 2
    8. La Domoiselle elue/Opera Arias
    9. Lo Sposalizio: The Wedding of Venice to the Sea
    10. Mahler: Symphony No .5

    Music Review

    music review

    Music Review

    Would Like to Pose a Question

    Three Double Concertos

    String Quartet 1 in E

    Shelf-Life

    This Is Clubnation, Vol. 2 [Import]

    Voyagers [Import]

    Tim Maia, Cassiano & Hyldon - Velhos Camaras V.2 [Import]

    The January Tree

    Twisted Wheel Forever [Import]

    The Hyperion Schubert Edition 18 / Peter Schreier, Graham Johnson

    This Time the Drums on Me [Import]

    Salsa Cubana [Import]

    Sere Tuya Esta Noche

    Cowboy Girl

    The United States Marine Band Performs Sousa Marches