Great Recordings Of The Century - Beethoven; Mendelssohn: Violin Concertos / Furtwangler, Menuhin

Editorial Reviews
Amazon.com essential recording
Yehudi Menuhin and Wilhelm Furtwängler, born a generation apart and separated by a world at war, were nonetheless musical and philosophical soulmates. Their recording of the Beethoven Violin Concerto, made seven years after they first met, is one of the treasures of the EMI archive, a testament to a bygone era of spontaneous and deeply subjective music-making. There is a nobility to the reading that has never been equaled, an unforced passion that would be difficult for any of today's musicians to duplicate. The monaural recording is remarkably fine, with satisfying depth and abundant detail. --Ted Libbey

Great Recordings Of The Century - Beethoven; Mendelssohn: Violin Concertos / Furtwangler, Menuhin, Music, Ludwig van Beethoven, Felix Mendelssohn, Wilhelm Furtwängler, Wilhelm Furtwangler, Yehudi Menuhin, Philharmonia Orchestra, Berlin Philharmonic, Chamber Music & Recitals, Classical, Classical Composers, Classical Music, Concerto, Violin Concerto

Great Recordings Of The Century - Beethoven; Mendelssohn: Violin Concertos / Furtwangler, Menuhin
Average customer rating:

Choosing between two versions from Menuhin and Furtwangler

Menuhin and Furtwangler Play Beethoven and Mendelssohn

The best of the romantic view

Huh?

Good, but Menuhin was sublime in Lucerne

Great Recordings Of The Century - Beethoven; Mendelssohn: Violin Concertos / Furtwangler, Menuhin
Wilhelm Furtwangler , Yehudi Menuhin , Philharmonia Orchestra , and Berlin Philharmonic
Manufacturer: EMI Classics
ProductGroup: Music
Binding: Audio CD

All Works by Beethoven | Beethoven, Ludwig van | ( B ) | Featured Composers, A-Z | Classical | Styles | Music
All Works by Mendelssohn | Mendelssohn, Felix | ( M ) | Featured Composers, A-Z | Classical | Styles | Music
General | Concertos | Forms & Genres | Classical | Styles | Music
Chamber Music | Forms & Genres | Classical (c.1770-1830) | Historical Periods | Classical | Styles | Music
General | Classical (c.1770-1830) | Historical Periods | Classical | Styles | Music
General Modern | Modern, 20th, & 21st Century | Historical Periods | Classical | Styles | Music
Violin | Strings | Instruments | Classical | Styles | Music
General | Classical | Styles | Music
General | Chamber Music | Classical | Styles | Music
Similar Items:

Great Recordings Of The Century - Beethoven: Symphony no 9 / Furtwangler, Schwarzkopf

Furtwangler Conducts Beethoven - Beethoven: symphonies no 3,4,5, & 9, Leonore

Great Recordings Of The Century - Beethoven: Triple Concerto; Brahms: Double Concerto / Oistrakh, Rostropovich, Richter

Recordings 1942-1944, Vol. 1

Furtwangler Conducts Brahms - Complete Symphonies, etc / North German RSO, Berlin PO

ASIN: B00000IOBJ
Release Date: 1999-05-04

Tracks:

Violin Concerto In D, Op. 61: 1. Allegro Ma non Troppo (Cadence: F. Kreisler)
Violin Concerto In D, Op. 61: 2. Larghetto
Violin Concerto In D, Op. 61: 3. Rondo (Allegro) (Cadence: F. Kreisler)
Violin Concerto In E Minor, Op. 64: 1. Allegro Molto Appassionato
Violin Concerto In E Minor, Op. 64: 2. Andante
Violin Concerto In E Minor, Op. 64: 3. Allegretto Non Troppo- Allegro Molto Vivace

Amazon.com essential recording

Yehudi Menuhin and Wilhelm Furtwängler, born a generation apart and separated by a world at war, were nonetheless musical and philosophical soulmates. Their recording of the Beethoven Violin Concerto, made seven years after they first met, is one of the treasures of the EMI archive, a testament to a bygone era of spontaneous and deeply subjective music-making. There is a nobility to the reading that has never been equaled, an unforced passion that would be difficult for any of today's musicians to duplicate. The monaural recording is remarkably fine, with satisfying depth and abundant detail. --Ted Libbey

Customer Reviews:

Choosing between two versions from Menuhin and Furtwangler.......2006-01-01

In the Beethoven, reviewers here consistently prefer the live 1947 radio broadcast from the Lucerne Festival over this 1953 studio recording from London. I'm not sure the choice is that clear, however, until one knows the salient details.

Lucerne 1947: Historically, this is a touching momento of Menuhin's decision to appear with Furtwangler soon after the war, at a time when the conductor's de-Nazification was slow and painful. Menuhin's gesture helped to rehabilitate Furtwangler in circles that had condemned him, and this Beethoven concerto performance shows how musically sympathetic the two artists were. Menuhin is placed far forward in Lucerne, his tone bright and at times shrill but nonetheless warm enough to listen to without wincing. His technique is adequate to the piece but no more.

Furtwangler gives almost an identical accompaniment in both recordings, although the Lucerne Festival Orchestra is notably less polished than the Philharmonia in the studio. Sonics are good radio mono. Tempos are the same in both recordings except for the slow movement, which is 2 min. slower in Lucerne. Menuhin opens the finale firmly and in tune.

1953 London: This studio recording is in quite good mono for its day, and the Philharmonia sounds especially warm and inviting. One notes a metallic edge in both orchestra and soloist at loud volumes (I haven't heard the latest remastering, which might have solved this problem). Menuhin's technique is no longer adequate to the part, though his interpretation hasn't changed in six years. He is quite out of tune beginning the finale, with gravelly tone on the G string. In both performances his approach is cautious rather than free and rhapsodic.

Furtwangler's accompaniment has great depth and lyric flow, without the drama he is capable of in Beethoven, however. It's often said that he felt constrained in the studio and freer in concert, but in this case both accounts are quite similar.
After all is said and done, the difference isn't so much interpretive but technical--Menuhin had slipped too far by 1953, at least to this listener.

The final and most important question is whether these are deeply felt and noble performances. Surprisingly, I didn't find them so this time around, but I did ten years ago. Subjectivity plays a crucial part in the role of the listener. I can sympathize with people who feel ennobled by these readings even though they have dimmed for me.

The Mendelssohn concerto from 1953 isn't an afterthought. This was always one of Menuhin's best pieces, and here he preforms it with moderate tempos and the kind of personal expression perfectly matched to Furtwangler's own. There are more mercurial readings but few as emotionally sympathetic.

Menuhin and Furtwangler Play Beethoven and Mendelssohn.......2005-10-11

The thirteenth-century poet Rumi wrote that "the voice of the violin is the sound of the opening gate of paradise." I was swept away by this classic recording of the Beethoven and Mendelssohn violin concertos by Yehudi Menuhin and Wilhelm Furtwangler conducting the Philharmonia Orchestra in the Beethoven and the Berlin Philharmonic in the Mendelsshon. This disk is a reissue on the "Great Recordings of the Century" series. The recordings date from 1953.

Wilhelm Furtwangler was one of the last of the romantic conductors. His tempos in these concertos are deliberate and fluid and the orchestral sound is lush. He recorded the Beethoven concerto with Menuhin in 1947 and again, on the version given here, in 1953. The first version emphasizes the lyrical, gracious character of the work. The version here is more reserved, emphasizing the spiritual, lofty character that many listeners find in the Beethoven violin concerto.

The Beethoven concerto is remarkable for its breadth and spaciousness and for the opportunity it accords for interplay between orchestra and soloist. The orchestral part is unusually detailed and elaborate and much of the violin part, especially in the opening movement, is filigree and embroidery in the highest register of the instrument around the orchestral themes. There are beautiful melodies in this work together with dramatic passages. In the first movement, the new listener should focus on how the opening five-beats of the tympani come to pervade the entire movement. The second movement is a theme and variations with two deeply-moving and reflective interludes for the violin. For many listeners, this movement is the climax of the entire work. The third movement is a lively rondo, more unbuttoned than the first two movements, with a great deal of variety and a lively coda.

Joseph Joachim, the 19th century violinist who championed both the Beethoven and the Mendelssohn concertos, among many others, said in 1906 (celebrating his 75th birthday) that "the greatest, the most uncompromising" of the violin concerto's was Beethoven's but that "the most inward, the heart's jewel" is Mendelssohn's". Furtwangler and Menuin's rendition of this most-frequently played of the violin concertos brought Joachim's words home for me.

Unlike the Beethoven concerto, the soloist is almost always at the center of attention in the Mendelssohn. Menuhin plays with lyricism and passion -- this work is much more than a series of pretty tunes. The orchestral part is detailed and developed, if subordinate to the soloist, and Furtwangler and the Berlin Philharmonic are equal partners to Menuhin's playing. This work is in three connected movements. In the opening, the new listener should focus on the long cadenza for the violin which Mendelssohn places following the development rather than in its usual place before the coda. The transition passages between the first and the second movement and the second and the third also are of great importance in this work. The second movement consists of a long songlike theme and the third movement is a light Mendelssohn scherzo. The performance here brings out the depths of this concerto.

This modestly-priced CD is an ideal way for the new listener to get to know two masterpieces for the violin concerto -- and two of the great works of music. The quotations I used earlier in the review are taken from the discussion of the Beethoven and Mendelssohn concertos in Michal Steinberg's book, "The Concerto: A Listener's Guide." Listeners interested in exploring the concerto literature will enjoy reading Steinberg's book.

Robin Friedman

The best of the romantic view.......2005-05-28

I first encountered this recording in a blue box of LPs imported from Germany by Odeon; simply entitled "Furtwangler", the box contains Beethoven's 3rd and 5th symphonies in the Vienna Philharmonic studio version; the Bayreuth version of the 9th; and the Emperor Concerto with Edwin Fischer and the Violin Concerto with Menuhin, both with the Philharmonia. The set was reprocessed by German Electrola in "Breitklang", which was a "space-opening" technology just this side of fake stereo. For at least a year I listened to the Menuhin record without much feeling one way or the other. Then one day I flipped the "mono" switch on my amplifier. All of a sudden, the fake "noise" that infected Menuhin's tone was gone, and there was his remarkable, sweet, luminous tone, a rare sound that shines from the inside. I was enthralled. I listened spellbound to one of the most personal, communicative renditions of this great piece I'd ever heard.

This is a lovely rendition, a bit more detached than the earlier Luzerne collaboration of these two great artists, perhaps less passionate but with a compensating spiritual depth. Menuhin may not have been the virtuoso he was 7 years earlier, but he still had most of his technique and sound intact. Yes, there are intonation problems, especially in the opening of the first movement. But we are a far distance from the Menuhin who sounded like he was struggling, with persistent intonation, bowing and phrasing problems and a tone which sounded increasing frayed. He might not be here the incandescent light he had been; but he was still a major artist with a deep spiritual insight into this piece and enough technique to bring it off.

Furtwanger, of course, is marvellous. Each phrase is lovingly and plastically molded, the overall structure and balance of the piece is always evident, each part fits inexorably into the whole, and all is at the service of his unique, spiritual (there's that word again) insight. The Philharmonia sounds like his own.

Rating this performance against the Luzerne version is like rating Furtwangler's late-life VPO/BPO studio recordings of Beethoven symphonies against his war-years radio broadcasts. The latter versions of both are more passionate, white-hot, intense; the former are a bit more removed, not without passion or feeling but with a more balanced perspective. Each version has its place, each offers its own unique insight. Each is worth listening to. Each is, in its own way, an essential recording.

You may hear this piece performed differently; you will never hear it performed better.

Huh?.......2004-12-31

I have more records of Menuhin than you could dream of a music fan! I have every single recording he did from 1928 Ries La Capricciosa to the latest recordings of concerti in the box set Menuhin concerto collection EMI. So I think my judgement is valid, the Lucerne recording on testament I have and I agree it's far better! Go Testament!

Good, but Menuhin was sublime in Lucerne.......2004-08-04

This is certainly a good recording of the Beethoven, and Furt's accompaniment is at times nothing short of stunning. But whereas Menuhin is merely good here, he is absolutely sublime in his earlier recording in Lucerne (also with Furt), which is now available on Testament. The EMI recording is cheapter, obviously, but don't let that mislead you: the Testament would be a bargain at any price.

Track Listings:

Track Listings

Emerson Lake & Palmer [Import]

Act Like You Know Me

A Little Moonlight

Bach Cantatas: 54; 169; 170

Abysmal Masquerade

An American Patchwork

Andrew Oh

20 Exitos De Oro Romantico

15 Canciones Favoritas

Lonesome Valley

Classics, Vol. 18