Track Listings
| 1. I Lost A Sock | ||
| 2. Acoustic Aphasia | ||
| 3. Passenger Pigeon | ||
| 4. Remix I | ||
| 5. When Any Man | ||
| 6. Remix II | ||
| 7. I Found My Enemy's Ox | ||
| 8. Fw:Fw: Please Look | ||
| 9. Remix III | ||
| 10. Lost Thing | ||
| 11. Two Are Holding | ||
| 12. Remix IV | ||
| 13. Not Our Darkness (Loss Of Meaning) | ||
| 14. We Were Enveloped |
Lost Objects, Music, Michael/ Lang, David/ Wolfe, Julia Gordon, Andrew Watts, Daniel Taylor, Concerto Köln, Claudia Barainsky, Choral, Choral Music, Classical, Classical Artists, Classical Music, Experimental, Orchestral & Symphonic
Average customer rating:
|
Lost Objects
Manufacturer: Elektra / Wea ProductGroup: Music Binding: Audio CD ASIN: B000059QW9 Release Date: 2001-05-15 |
Tracks:
Customer Reviews:
Annoying/Beautiful.......2002-07-21
Dreadful and dull. buy some earlier Michael Gordon instead........2002-04-10
Not only was I thouroughly disappointed at this, I was actually infuriated at how incredibly dull and irritating it was. Rather than being a bold step (at least for minimalist-influenced composers) forward into newer rhythmic and harmonic territories as was represented to a degree by some of the aforementioned compositions, 'Lost Objects' represents a step backwards into the very safe but entirely uninteresting realm of mediocre, routine and incredibly predictable minimalism (not to imply that all minimalism is uninteresting, as I do not believe that this is the case, but this certainly is).
I have the feeling with this CD that the composers could almost have written it in their sleep, and that's what really gets me; because they are composers capable of music so much more interesting and vibrant than this. Much of it resembles someone trying to sound like John Adams, but but possessing neither the sense of colour, form or scale to pull it off.
Furthermore, I feel that it fails in terms of the "crossover" attempt at fusing rock elements and instrumentation with that of classical or contemporary classical, and as a result disappoints on both counts. Not only does it lack the rhythmic vibrancy of rock (or indeed of earlier BOAC releases, or those by Icebreaker) but it also lapses into all of the usual minimalist cliches (for example, listen to the very typical minimalist endings of tracks 2, 3, 5 & 10).
If you're looking for a good minimalist work with orchestra and choir, then go and buy the Nonesuch release of John Adams' 'Harmonium', or Steve Reich's 'The Desert Music' - they each have so much more going for them.
In short: 'Lost Objects' is by-the-numbers minimalism minus the patience, spirit and artistry of classics such as 'Music for 18 Musicians' and 'Shaker Loops' to name but two. If you're expecting the edgy sound of earlier Bang on a Can releases, then you will be disappointed by this release. Go and seek out the earlier BOAC release 'Industry', or Gordon's works 'Weather' or 'Trance'; even try some Louis Andriessen, all worth a listen. I think that Gordon, Wolfe & Lang really missed the mark with 'Lost Objects'.
An album worth listening to.......2002-02-24
what is this beautiful thing?.......2001-09-10
Avoid this, unlessý.......2001-08-14
So why did I buy it in the first place ? Probably because I felt I had to give this kind of "trendy" stuff a fair try. "Lost Objects" being sort of heavily promoted here in France, I decided to pick that one. Also, "Bang on a can" projects seem to be getting quite good reviews here and there, and the amazon review was enthusiastic.
Unfortunately, repeated listenings did not uncover beauties. Quite the opposite : it revealed (to my ears at least) the shallowness of the compositions. Luckily, I was able to get a refund from the store and got myself the Ligeti "studies for piano" instead, which I enjoy tremendously. I confess I never managed to appreciate Phil Glass, Steve Reich, and the other so-called "minimalists". That should give you an idea of my "background". I'm more into "maximalist" stuff : STRAVINSKY, WEBERN, BACH, and JOHN ZORN. And I do love MORTON FELDMAN and SCELSI ). Also, if you want to get a real kick out of music, try JANACEK. It's packed with emotion, without being sentimental, it's adventurous but not esoteric. But beware, it might turn into an ADDICTION !!
Average customer rating: |
Objects in Mirror Are Closer Than They Appear
Manufacturer: BVHaast ProductGroup: Music Binding: Audio CD ASIN: B000BKFFV8 |
Tracks:
Track Listings:
Track Listings
Dialogo con Armando Gentilucci
Elaine Paige [Import] [Original recording remastered]
Franz Schubert: Complete Piano Works Vol. 12