Haydn: String Quartets, Op. 64, Nos. 1-3
Editorial Reviews
From International Record Review - subscribe now
The interpretative temperature of these performances is, as one would expect from The Lindsays, consistently high. So expressively alert, they bring a sense of purpose to every note: sforzandos are arresting and powerful, faster movements are high on adrenalin. Above all, The Lindsays are surely hard to surpass in their delivery of Haydn's slow movements. In the Adagio of No. 2 they sustain a rapturous atmosphere, and that of No. 3 is also wonderfully elevated. There is intense concentration, yet also a directness and warmth that will captivate every listener. Strangely less persuasive, though, is their Allegretto 'slow movement' in No. 1: there must be more delicacy to the humour than this rather broad approach would allow. The sense of commitment and character is strengthened by the relatively close and dry recorded sound. This also exposes, though, a tendency for tone and tuning to suffer under the pressure of the interpretative moment. Caution is simply not part of the way The Lindsays make music, but might they sometimes have been more self-critical? The outer movements of No. 1 bring some lack of rhythmic poise, given the tendency to accelerate through animated passages. A certain skittishness seems just right in the former, but the swallowing of beats in the finale detracts from the excitement. The sustained aggressiveness of the B minor finale cannot really accommodate the fade-out ending. A more whimsical version from the Angeles Quartet makes better sense of this concluding surprise.The Angeles, more warmly recorded, are certainly superior in the traditional quartet virtues of balance and blend, but honours are pretty even when I consider my reactions to the accounts of individual movements. I find both groups relatively disappointing in the outer movements of No. 3; more could be done with the timing of the galloping motive in the first movement as well as the strangely stuttering chord sequences in the finale. But no one could be disappointed with the best of The Lindsays' performances here: put on those slow movements and surrender yourself. W. Dean Sutcliffe
Haydn: String Quartets, Op. 64, Nos. 1-3, Music, Franz Joseph Haydn, Lindsays String Quartet, Chamber, Chamber Music & Recitals, Classical, Classical Composers, Classical Music, Quartet for Four String Instruments
Average customer rating:
|
Haydn: String Quartets Op 64 Nos 1, 3, 6 /Quatuor Mosaiques
Joseph Haydn , Quatuor Mosaiques , Anita Mitterer , Erich Hobarth , Andrea Bischof , and Christophe Coin Manufacturer: Astree ProductGroup: Music Binding: Audio CD Similar Items:
ASIN: B0000C8WXL Release Date: 2004-01-20 |
Tracks:
Customer Reviews:
Another Haydn Triumph For Quatuor Mosaiques.......2007-05-28
Average customer rating:
|
Haydn: String Quartets Op. 64, Nos. 1, 2 and 3
Manufacturer: Naxos ProductGroup: Music Binding: Audio CD Similar Items:
ASIN: B0000013W3 Release Date: 1994-02-15 |
Tracks:
Customer Reviews:
Exploring the Haydn Quartets -- Opus 64 No. 1-3.......2004-05-30
The first quartet of the set, in C major, is serene and happy in character. The first movement is an allegro moderato which opens with a bouncy theme in the solo violin which is soon taken up by the entire quartet. There is counterpoint in the minor in the development, and the recapitulation, surprisingly, is extended and varies the exposition by shifting to the minor key just before the end. This quartet lacks a slow movement. The second movement is a minuet which features a whimsical theme in the cello. The third movement is a scherzo which is angular in character and slightly faster than the minuet. It consists of a lengthy theme which is repeated and embellished twice -- almost a variation movement. The finale is marked presto and features dramatic pauses and stops and a piping theme in the violin's high register. The movement and the quartet come to a sudden, quiet ending.
Although the first quartet lacks a slow movement, this lack is more than compensated in the lovely adagios in the second and third quartets on this CD.
The second quartet is in B-minor and is somber in character. The first movement, allegro spirituoso, opens with a short violin solo followed by a dramatic turn to the minor. The movement increases in intensity as it progresses. The second movement, adagio ma non troppo, is an extended slow movement with a lyrical theme and long note values. The theme is stated in the first violin and echoed in the cello and middle strings. As the theme is developed it is elaborated with filigree in the violin and a restatement of the theme in the cello. The third movement is a minuet which returns to the minor. It features a peaceful, lyrical trio in which the violin has the lead. This theme in the trio echoes the slow movement of the quartet. The finale is marked presto and is again in the minor. The movement increases in dramatic intensity until its quiet end in the high register of the violin.
I found the third quartet in B-Flat major the most enjoyable of the three on this disk. The quartet is lively and energetic, with unusual rhythms, lots of trills, and a slow movement even more extended that that of the b-minor quartet. There is excellent contrast and continuity in the movements of this work.
The first movement, vivace assai, opens in unison with the opening theme followed by a flowing second theme stated in the violin. There are many delicious twists and turns in this movement, particularly the trills over the cello and the running themes in the violin. The second movement is marked adagio. It is a lengthy movement which opens with a slow, meditative theme followed by an intense, plaintive middle section and a return of the opening material. The minuet is lively, emphatic, and rhythmic, featuring many trilling sections in the middle and lower strings and a cello drone in the trio. The finale is lively with a short, falling, carefree figure repeated many times by the first violin. There is a contrast in this movement between quick and slow sections. There is a short slow section just before the end and then a jolly close in unison.
These quartets were written to be played by amateurs and to be enjoyed by their listeners. Even more than is the case with his symphonies, Haydn established a standard in his quartet writing that subsequent composers emulated and developed. There is much excellent music in these quartets that remains to be appreciated and discovered. This CD will reward exploration both by listeners new to chamber music and to experienced listeners.
Average customer rating: |
JOSEPH HAYDN String Quartets op.64 Nos. 1-3 Vienna Masters Series Digital Classic Germany Import
Manufacturer: Pilz ProductGroup: Classical Binding: Audio CD ASIN: B000JJVM3Q |
Product Description
Vienna Masters Series, Digital Classic, Germany Import
Average customer rating: |
Haydn: String Quartets, Op. 64, Nos. 1-3
Manufacturer: Asv Living Era ProductGroup: Music Binding: Audio CD ASIN: B00005OVYS Release Date: 2001-10-23 |
Tracks:
Average customer rating: |
Haydn: String Quartets Op.76, Nos. 1, 5, 6
Manufacturer: Angel Records ProductGroup: Music Binding: Audio CD Similar Items:
ASIN: B00002CF1J Release Date: 1999-11-02 |
Tracks:
Average customer rating: |
Franz Joseph Haydn: "Tost" String Quartets, Op. 64 Nos. 1-3
Manufacturer: Hyperion ProductGroup: Music Binding: Audio CD ASIN: B00000300D Release Date: 1996-08-10 |
Track Listings:
Track Listings
Emily Dickinson: A Different Slant of Light