Wilhelm Peterson-Berger: Symphonies 1 and 5

1. Symphony No. 1 in B flat major ("Banéret")
Composed by Wilhelm Peterson-Berger
Performed by Stockholm Royal Opera Orchestra Conducted by Leif Segerstam

2. Symphony No. 5 in B minor ("Solitudo")
Composed by Wilhelm Peterson-Berger
Performed by Stockholm Royal Opera Orchestra Conducted by Leif Segerstam

Wilhelm Peterson-Berger: Symphonies 1 and 5,Wilhelm Peterson-Berger,Leif Segerstam,Stockholm Royal Opera Orchestra,Sterling [Qualiton],Classical,Classical Composers,Orchestral & Symphonic,Symphonic,Symphony

Average customer rating: One very good indeed, another not quite so magnificent Unjustly neglected syphonies well worth a listen.

Wilhelm Peterson-Berger: Symphonies 1 and 5 Manufacturer: Sterling [Qualiton] ProductGroup: Music Binding: Audio CD General | Symphonies | Classical | Styles | Music General | Classical | Styles | Music ASIN: B00000455I Release Date: 2000-09-30

Tracks:

1. Sym No.1 in B flat 'Baneret': I. 'Nar Vi Forst Drogo Ut'. Allegro, Un Poco Moderato
2. Sym No.1 in B flat 'Baneret': II. 'Mellan Fejderna'. Allegro Scherzando, Non Troppo Moto
3. Sym No.1 in B flat 'Baneret': III. 'Vid Hjaltebaren'. Lento Doloroso Con Gravita
4. Sym No.1 in B flat 'Baneret': IV. 'Mot Nya Varar'. Allegro Moderato--Largo Maestoso
5. Sym No.5 in b 'Solitudo': I. Con moto tranquillo
6. Sym No.5 in b 'Solitudo': II. Scherzando Vivo, Delicatissimo--Allegro moderato
7. Sym No.5 in b 'Solitudo': III. Andante Tranquillo
8. Sym No.5 in b 'Solitudo': IV. Allegro Molto--Andante Molto Tranquillo

Customer Reviews:

One very good indeed, another not quite so magnificent.......2006-10-07

This is in some respect a Janus-faced disc, showing the extremes of Peterson-Berger's symphonic output. On the one hand the First Symphony, which is very much a first effort: ambitious yet somewhat lacking in ideas and compositional tightness. It is to his later symphonies what Bruckner's first symphony is to, say, the sixth; showing the outlines of greatness but lacking the necessary depth.

The fifth, on the other hand, is marvellous music, rich in ideas and marvellously developed. Its subtitle, 'solitude', makes clear that the large gestures of the second and third 'Same Atnam" symphonies are not predominant in this work. Rather, it is subtlety that dominates. The scherzo, rightly titled 'delicatissimo', is a clear indication. No spectacular codas here; all movements end rather quietly. The finale, however, is very rhytmic, with the sort of 'perpetual movement' that pervades the last movements of Schubert's ninth or Raff's eleventh. A great piece, that deserves far more attention than it has sofar received.

Segerstam's forces are just the ones to challenge these works. However, it must be said that there's little in it between his recording and Michail Jurowski's equally excellent one on CPO. Segerstam's first is a little better, but the work I'd buy this CD for would be the fifth symphony.

P.s. unfortunately, these reviews have sometimes become a medium to vent dogmatic views on what is good music and what is not (e.g. review by 'Homer' elsewhere on this page). My star rating here refers to playing and interpretation, not the intrinsic musical value of either symphony - that is a matter of aesthetics that everyone needs to decide for him- or herself.

Unjustly neglected syphonies well worth a listen........1999-07-06

Ultra conservative Swedish symphonies from an exact contemporary of Sibelius, Nielsen, Stenhammar and Alfven. Nordic pastoralism meets Wagner and the military band! Highly enjoyable! Considering the middle symphonies of Dvorak get programed with some regularity, the neglect of these attractive works is beyond understanding. Enthusiastic performances, well recorded--low volume level, however.

Track Listings:

1. Works for Transverse Flute 2
2. 1539 Music for the Wedding of the Duke of Florence
3. A Touch of Latin
4. Baroque Guitar Quartets
5. Barrios: Guitar Music
6. Beethoven: Piano Concerto, No.5/Symphony No.1
7. Beethoven: Piano Sonatas, Op. 31, Nos. 1-3
8. Beethoven: Three Hymns, Op. 86
9. Beloved Bach
10. Blake Songs & Other Works by Jonathan Lovenstein

Track Listings

track listings

Track Listings

Days of Speed: Live & Acoustic [Import]

L'Héritage De Willem Mengelberg-Cycle Piotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky, Vol. 4 - Symphony No. 5 (recorded 1940 in Berlin); Serenade for Strings (recorded 1937 in Amsterdam)

I've Got a Crush on You

Music: Is This Real?

Hermetic Jukebox [Import]

I Never Told You

Just Right for God

germanbooks88.com Music: 1001 Ways to Be Romantic: The Music

Just Call Me Hank

Gilberto With Turrentine [Import]

Higher [CD-single] [Import] [Limited Edition]

Haunted Shores

Gigaplus [Import]

Holst: The Planets

Only the Very Best of the Makaha Sons: Heke Wale